One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest is a movie that seems like you’ve seen it even if you haven’t. I finally watched it. Full disclosure—my real reason was that I wanted to have context for the new Netflix show Nurse Ratched starring Sarah Paulson.
My initial reaction to the film is, whoa, I need to unpack this.
The movie is set during the fall of 1963, but released in 1975, and it’s striking how much happened in America during that time, including the Kennedy assassination, civil rights, the Vietnam War, the Watergate scandal, and the women’s movement. We can see both the wide-ranging changes and the reaction to it in this story.
For example, when we first meet Jack Nicholson’s McMurphy, the casual sexism that both he and the doctor interviewing him display is perfectly normal. They joke over his statutory rape conviction that landed him in prison, what McMurphy calls the “work farm.” Like Hamlet, McMurphy has been pretending to be mentally ill, but unlike the Danish prince, all McMurphy wants is an easier way to finish out his sentence at the state mental hospital.
Perhaps in another sign of the times, the only people of color we see are orderlies working at the hospital. All the patients are white men, except for one Native American character who McMurphy nicknames “Chief,” a nod to casual racism to match his sexism. Interestingly, we later learn that Chief is only pretending to be a deaf-mute man, which forms a parallel to McMurphy’s play-acting. Both men meet drastically different fates though.
What strikes me is how much potential these men would’ve had if only their circumstances were different. McMurphy is an “outside the box” rabble-rouser who just as easily could’ve been an entrepreneur, while Chief’s stoic bravery might’ve transformed him into a significant leader. They reminded me a little of Stringer Bell and Omar Little in The Wire. I always thought, if only they had other opportunities who knows what amazing things they might’ve accomplished instead?
I think that gender politics are more in the foreground in this movie. The villain is a middle-aged woman who is controlling and limits the fun of her male patients. Nurse Ratched is a master class in passive-aggressiveness. Don’t get me wrong, she’s a sociopath, but isn’t that maybe the only way that a woman in that world could wield any power? I wonder if all her empathy and “do no harm” sensibilities have been corrupted by the patriarchy. Or is she a monster drawn to nursing because she can inflict the maximum amount of pain on the vulnerable?
Nurse Ratched seems to have met her match in McMurphy—or so it seems. I think his fatal flaw is that he doesn’t take his opponent seriously. Ratched can inflict pain and ultimately permanent damage on him. The establishment is simply too strong for a libertine like McMurphy.
On some level, I wonder if his heart is even in this war because he passes up major opportunities to escape. Again, this might be because he doesn’t take the danger he’s in seriously, but it’s frustrating to watch him scale the hospital fence just to take the other patients on a fishing adventure. And later, he chooses not to climb out the open window when he stages a party once Ratched leaves for the night.
Another way to read this, of course, is that McMurphy has bonded with the other patients and feels protective of them, especially the stuttering Billy. It’s heartbreaking to watch how Nurse Ratched dismantles all of Billy’s confidence after he’s discovered with the prostitute. She wields guilt with as much surgical precision as McMurphy incites chaos.
Instead of escaping, McMurphy snaps and starts to strangle Nurse Ratched. This a brief moment of triumph for both him and the audience, but it ultimately fails. It’s an impotent gesture, and one that we discover neuters McMurphy permanently with a subsequent lobotomy. Is this a comment on the sexual revolution and the changing power dynamics in America at the time? Given this, it’s interesting that the only person to escape is a calm and determined man who stays out of the battle and waits for his opportunity to gain freedom.